Go to https://surfshark.com/graham or use code GRAHAM at checkout to get 4 extra months of Surfshark VPN! | Let’s discuss the “Stocks Never Go Down” Theory, and why the US might continue pushing prices higher – Enjoy! Add me on Instagram: GPStephan
START BUILDING WEALTH WITH MY FREE NEWSLETTER: https://grahamstephan.substack.com
THE “STOCKS NEVER GO DOWN” THEORY
A viral Reddit post claims the stock market can “literally never go down again” because the U.S. owes nearly $40 trillion, interest costs are rising, and the government will eventually be forced to print money. The argument is that inflation would push stocks higher forever, making crashes impossible. The video breaks down why that idea feels believable, where it has some truth, and why it is still dangerously wrong.
THE GREAT MELT-UP
The theory is really a version of the “great melt-up,” where markets enter a final euphoric phase driven less by earnings and cash flow and more by momentum, FOMO, and the belief that prices will keep rising because they have been rising. This has happened before, including the Dotcom bubble, when the Nasdaq rose roughly 400% from 1995 to 2000 before falling 78%, and Japan’s bubble, where stocks rose 900% before collapsing and taking decades to recover.
WHY THE THEORY FEELS TRUE
The U.S. has massive debt, large deficits, rising money supply, and a government incentive to inflate away what it owes. Historically, governments often reduce debt through “financial repression,” where inflation runs higher than interest rates and the real value of debt shrinks over time. In that environment, assets like stocks can rise in dollar terms because the dollars used to measure them are losing value.
WHY STOCKS COULD KEEP RISING
Stocks represent ownership in real businesses that can raise prices, own hard assets, and earn money globally. If the dollar loses purchasing power, many of those businesses may continue rising in nominal terms. AI also gives investors a real reason to be optimistic, with major firms raising S&P 500 targets and expecting more earnings growth. That makes the melt-up thesis plausible, but not guaranteed.
WHY THE MARKET IS STILL RISKY
The problem is that today’s stock market is extremely expensive by most valuation metrics. The CAPE ratio has only gone above 40 twice in modern history: during the Dotcom bubble and today. Stocks are more expensive than they were before 1929 and 2008, and the only time they were more expensive was near the peak of Dotcom mania. That does not mean a crash is guaranteed, but it means investors are paying a very high price for future growth.
THE REDDIT POST GETS KEY DETAILS WRONG
The Reddit post says interest payments are about to exceed GDP, which is false. It also says the only way to pay interest is to print money, which is not currently true because the government can still sell Treasuries to investors. Finally, it assumes stocks automatically inflate proportionally during hyperinflation, but history shows that markets can collapse in real terms even when nominal prices eventually rise.
INFLATION DOES NOT GUARANTEE REAL WEALTH
Stocks can rise during inflation without making investors richer. If your portfolio rises 10% but everything you buy also costs 10% more, your real purchasing power has not improved. Germany, Zimbabwe, Venezuela, and even the U.S. in the 1970s show that inflation can destroy real returns, force people to sell at the worst time, and make nominal gains misleading.
THE MOST LIKELY OUTCOME
The U.S. probably does not default, does not enter true hyperinflation, and does not experience a straight-line stock melt-up forever. The more realistic outcome is a long period of financial repression, where inflation runs slightly above interest rates, taxes rise, spending growth slows, and the debt becomes easier to manage over time. Asset prices may rise in dollar terms, but real returns could be much lower than investors expect.
THE SMART INVESTOR TAKEAWAY
The Reddit post is directionally right but mechanically wrong. In a high-debt world, assets are likely better than cash over long periods, but believing stocks cannot fall is extremely dangerous. The market can still drop 30%, 40%, or 60% and eventually make new highs later. The better approach is to stay diversified, avoid excessive leverage, keep enough cash to avoid forced selling, and not build your entire financial future around a viral internet thesis.
For business inquiries, you can reach me at grahamstephanbusiness@gmail.com
*Some of the links and other products that appear on this video are from companies which Graham Stephan will earn an affiliate commission or referral bonus. Graham Stephan is part of an affiliate network and receives compensation for sending traffic to partner sites. The content in this video is accurate as of the posting date. Some of the offers mentioned may no longer be available. This is not investment advice.
source
