rewrite this title Nigeria’s New Crypto Tax Law: A Strategic Move for Revenue or a Barrier to Growth?

Nigeria’s Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) recently hinted at introducing new regulations to tax cryptocurrency transactions.

It claimed the bill is part of its drive to build a trustworthy, data-driven tax system aligned with Nigeria’s economic objectives. 

The new crypto tax bill, which was expected to be introduced in the country’s legislative chambers in September 2024, is expected to lay the groundwork to help modernize the nation’s tax system and address the rapid growth of the cryptocurrency market.

Nigeria has been a global leader in cryptocurrency adoption, particularly among developing nations. It is one of the largest crypto markets globally, with high levels of peer-to-peer (P2P) trading volume and significant use cases for remittances and payments. So, it is important to ask if this new law will facilitate growth, as the tax agency claimed, or stifle it, especially considering Nigeria’s role in the broader context of the industry.

Key Features of the New Crypto Tax Bill

One of the core elements of Nigeria’s new crypto tax bill is a 7.5% VAT on cryptocurrency transactions. However, this tax applies specifically to service fees rather than the total value of the cryptocurrency being transferred. For instance, if a user pays a fee to transfer Bitcoin or another digital currency, only that fee is subject to VAT.

The bill is also expected to target several key aspects of cryptocurrency transactions, including:

Service Fees: Any charges associated with services provided by cryptocurrency platforms, such as trading or withdrawal fees, will be taxed.
Operational Costs: Expenses tied to managing cryptocurrency transactions, like administrative or processing fees, are also expected to be subject to VAT.

The specifics of the new tax rates and how they will be applied remain unclear, and detailed information has yet to be released. However, speculation suggests that certain elements of crypto transactions could see more targeted taxation in the coming months.

Why the Nigerian Government Introduced the Bill

The Nigerian government’s timing is strategic. Over the past few years, Nigeria’s crypto market has boomed, with crypto transaction volume increasing by 9% year-over-year to $56.7 billion between July 2022 and June 2023, according to Reuters. This rapid growth presents both opportunities and risks for the government.

From a revenue perspective, the government sees the cryptocurrency sector as a largely untapped resource. Traditional revenue streams, especially oil, have come under increasing pressure, prompting Nigeria to diversify its income sources. With the crypto market growing quickly, taxing digital transactions offers a new and sustainable source of revenue that aligns with the country’s economic objectives. Notably, the bill is reportedly expected to allow FIRS to achieve its N19 trillion revenue target within 12 calendar months.

At the same time, the government has expressed concerns about the unregulated nature of cryptocurrencies. In the past, authorities linked the rise of digital currencies to illegal activities such as money laundering, tax evasion, and the funding of illicit operations. By introducing this bill, the government aims to mitigate these risks, increase transparency, and create a regulatory framework for a market that has operated in a legal grey area for too long.

The Nigerian government has already begun taking action against “non-compliant” players in the country’s crypto space, including a lawsuit against Binance for tax evasion. The new bill represents another proactive approach to managing these risks while capitalizing on the potential financial benefits.

Implications for Nigeria’s Crypto Ecosystem

Nigeria’s new crypto tax law will have significant implications beyond merely increasing revenue. By establishing a regulated environment for cryptocurrency activities, the government aims to position Nigeria as a stable and predictable market for crypto ventures. This formalization could attract foreign investments and foster innovation in the country’s burgeoning digital economy.

One immediate consequence of the new VAT will be its effect on traders who engage in frequent, low-margin microtransactions. As Olaleye Awe, founder of Alpha Training Lab, rightly pointed out, the impact of these new regulations on smaller traders might be disastrous. A 7.5% VAT on service fees may not seem significant for large transactions, but for users who engage in frequent microtransactions, these costs can add up quickly. 

The added transaction costs may deter smaller traders, potentially reducing overall market activity. It also could push out many who rely on smaller, frequent trades, leading to a less dynamic but possibly more stable market if larger institutional players fill the gap.

For crypto-focused companies in Nigeria, the new tax regulations bring both challenges and opportunities. While increased compliance costs and more complex tax reporting requirements may create short-term burdens, the long-term benefits of a more regulated and stable market are significant. Companies that adapt to the new rules and align their operations with the regulatory framework may benefit from the increased investor confidence and potential influx of foreign capital.

However, it remains to be seen whether this bill will encourage further innovation in the sector or hinder the growth of small players. While larger crypto exchanges may be able to absorb these new costs, smaller companies and individual traders might find it harder to operate under the added tax burden.

While the new tax law is designed to bring order to Nigeria’s rapidly expanding crypto sector, it also opens up potential loopholes. For instance, how will the government ensure compliance among decentralized and peer-to-peer platforms? These platforms operate outside of traditional financial systems, making it harder to track transactions and enforce tax obligations. Without a robust monitoring framework, there is a risk that many traders and platforms could evade taxes altogether.

Another potential risk lies in driving crypto activity into unregulated channels. If traders and companies feel that the tax burden is too high or the regulatory framework is too restrictive, they might shift their activities to underground or offshore exchanges. This would not only hurt the government’s revenue generation efforts but also increase the likelihood of fraudulent or illegal activities.

To better understand Nigeria’s approach, it’s helpful to look at other countries that have imposed taxes on crypto. South Africa, for instance, imposes capital gains taxes on crypto-to-crypto transactions. In the U.S., crypto earnings are treated as property, meaning that capital gains taxes apply when users sell their digital assets for a profit. While these measures have provided clarity, they have also been met with challenges such as tax evasion and difficulties in tracking transactions.

Nigeria could face similar issues, especially since much of the country’s cryptocurrency activity takes place on peer-to-peer platforms, which are harder to regulate. South Africa’s experience shows that it’s possible to tax cryptocurrencies, but it requires robust infrastructure to prevent loopholes and ensure compliance.

Broader Implications for African Markets

Nigeria’s new law could have a ripple effect across Africa. As the continent’s largest crypto market, its regulatory stance will likely influence how other African nations approach the issue. Countries like Kenya and Ghana, which have seen rapid growth in crypto adoption, may look to Nigeria’s new law as a template for their own regulations. 

As mentioned earlier, South Africa already has capital gains taxes on crypto-to-crypto trades, and Nigeria’s new law could inspire similar regulatory efforts across Africa.

A more unified regulatory environment could benefit cross-border crypto businesses and provide a level of legitimacy to digital assets in the broader African market. However, if Nigeria’s tax law proves too restrictive, it could set a precedent for overregulation, potentially stifling the growth of the sector not just in Nigeria but across the African continent.

Final Thoughts

Nigeria’s new crypto tax law represents an important step toward formalizing the digital currency market and generating additional government revenue. However, the question remains: Will this law serve as a significant revenue generator for Nigeria, or will it act as a barrier to the growth of the crypto sector?

Rume Dominic, CEO of VOREM, told local media outlet Daily Trust that he sees the tax rules as a positive step toward integrating cryptocurrencies into the mainstream financial system. He believes that clear regulations, coupled with the taxation of cryptocurrency transactions, could significantly bolster government revenue over time. While challenges may arise, Dominic argues that the long-term benefits outweigh the short-term difficulties.

Another industry expert, Emmanuel Ndubuisi, CEO of Emforex Trading Academy, supports the tax initiative but emphasizes the importance of nurturing the sector.

“We should aim to create a thriving environment for crypto, not just impose taxes,”

he suggests.

“It’s vital that both the industry and the government benefit from these changes.”

In the end, the success of this new tax law will depend on how well Nigeria balances regulation with innovation. If done right, the law could solidify Nigeria’s position as a leader in Africa’s digital economy. However, if mismanaged, it could slow down the growth of one of the country’s most promising sectors.

Disclaimer: This article is intended solely for informational purposes and should not be. considered trading or investment advice. Nothing herein should be construed as financial, legal, or tax advice. Trading or investing in cryptocurrencies carries a considerable risk of financial loss. Always conduct due diligence. 

If you would like to read more market analyses like this, visit DeFi Planet and follow us on Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and CoinMarketCap Community. “Take control of your crypto  portfolio with MARKETS PRO, DeFi Planet’s suite of analytics tools.”